10 Oct 2017 20:53:34
What 2 players would you like to see Celtic sign. I'd love to see us sign James Maclean and James McCarthy. Think these 2 would be happy to see out the rest of their careers at Celtic Park. What a pair to have in the team when we seal 10 in a row. Both would excel under BR and playing for the club they support.
11 Oct 2017 11:03:26
Agree 100% stan both love the club and both good players.
11 Oct 2017 11:15:23
Think were covered in both areas lads, and unless mccarthy runs out his contract he will never be our player, mclean would be possible but would rather use the money it would cost to keep paddy.
11 Oct 2017 11:16:51
I don't think McLean is as good as Sinclair or Roberts tbh.
11 Oct 2017 11:24:25
Me. And if I'm injured, Messi as back up.
I agree with BW in that I could only see McCarthy signing on a free, and once Armstrong leaves. I also agree with Kev in that I'd rather have Sinclair and Paddy over McClean.
11 Oct 2017 13:36:14
Surely Maclean over Hayes? McCarthys Everton career is over a loan deal with a view to permanent deal would be possible. At the end of the day he will decide where he wants to play and he's made no secret of the fact he would love to sign. Think both would be great additions for the long term.
11 Oct 2017 14:06:34
My worry with McCarthy is that he has had some big injury concerns the last few years.
As for McLean he would be another Neil Lennon who would need security with him everywhere he goes plus it would be a lot of money to pay for a guy who would probably only be back up to Sinclair.
11 Oct 2017 16:03:04
I would like mcginn think he's developing well.
11 Oct 2017 21:56:40
I don't think McLean or Mccarthy would improve the team or squad at all, other than numerically. I also think that if McLean wasn't so forthcoming with his pro-Irish views, we wouldn't really know anything about him as he is such an ordinary player.