24 Oct 2025 15:38:33
I think Kenny showed why he should have been playing in the team last year and the year before, rather than playing Idah, Kenny brings souch more to the team in an attacking sense, but Idah cost nine million, so he had to be played, Idah scored goals but the team didn't perform as well, if Kenny had been playing, he might not have scored as many goals but the team would have, and won many more games, last year I would have played Kenny in the middle and Maeda on the left wing, which I think is his best position, ok Maeda might not have scored as many goals, but the team would have played better, and played more entertaining football.
24 Oct 2025 16:27:01
Unsurprisingly I don’t agree.
Kenny will give us 100% but he’s unfortunately not good enough to be a Celtic player.
Giving Kenny a big contract extension is more proof that Celtic have downsized as a club.
24 Oct 2025 17:31:55
He offers lots apart from goals.
24 Oct 2025 19:43:41
Our Manager has said many times that a player should be at Celtic for 3 years max.
A lot of our first team are at that juncture and may be thinking they should have moved or maybe it's time to move.
CCV hasn't been his best for quite some time, neither has Reo.
There have been rumours over many windows about them moving and they haven't, it is possible they have reached there ceiling with us.
Khun would have been the same imo, even Kyogo went off the boil. Once its in their heads it must difficult to get over it and get on with it.
Maeda is another who's head was turned and isn't the same player as last year.
Nobody has made any reference to Scales going anywhere and he just gets his head down and gives his all.
We are at the end of a cycle and there will be, or should be, a lot of changes in the summer.
{Ed007's Note - I honestly think CCV has reached his ceiling, he'll never play for a "top" team. The summer we signed him his agent spent the whole window trying to get him a move but the big red flag all the scouting reports etc flagged up was his lack of height and poor ariel ability.
I went through a stage of fancying trying to play him at CDM but I've now realised it was nuclear strength gummies to blame for that ?
24 Oct 2025 20:38:12
Ed do you think this is murrays big chance or will brendan go with trusty.
24 Oct 2025 20:50:44
I think for long periods he was great but couldn't deny his errors in big games,
24 Oct 2025 23:22:09
Ed, gummies…. We talking edibles ?.
{Ed007's Note - ???
24 Oct 2025 23:31:24
I think Murray will be a great centre half, and Buzz, did you think Adam Idah was good enough to play for Celtic, give Kenny the game time and the goals will come.
25 Oct 2025 18:16:32
Tbh Ed, I would have kept Nawroki and let CCV go at one point.
Watching the team on some occasions this year, we should all have been on gummies. ???.
{Ed007's Note - I've never been CCVs biggest fan, I just think he's too soft to be a CB for us imo, he's naturally as strong as an ox but he doesn't use it enough
Sure when we're in possession he could play with slippers on passing the ball about but when we need a proper old school CB he falls miles short for me.}