09 Jan 2014 15:33:11
If it is true that EPL clubs are wanting Van Dyck (£10m mentioned) what about this idea?
Take the £10m and buy Gauld, Robertson and Mackay Stevens from Dundee United for about £6m. These are 3 up and coming players whose value will only increase.
OK we lose Virgil but I think these 3 players would improve us and we still have money left over to put towards a proven goalscorer, my own preference would be Ings or Rhodes.
Celtic sign good British talent with massive potential and sell on fees in the future. Timalloy

1.) 09 Jan 2014
09 Jan 2014 16:59:23
Are dundee utd not valuing Gauld at £6m? Why should they sell for less than they value him

2.) 09 Jan 2014
If they think they will get that kind of money for a seventeen year old playing in the SPFL they are kidding themselves.

3.) 09 Jan 2014
As much as I rate Gauld (+ a few others), I don't think Dundee Utd are that financially well off that they can demand top dollar for a few teenagers.

4.) 09 Jan 2014
09 Jan 2014 18:34:45
They could hold out for top dollar for there top player if they wer to sell 1 or 2 others, if they get 1.5m for Robertson 1.5 mcay steven, 1m each Armstrong and soutar

5.) 09 Jan 2014
09 Jan 2014 18:36:21
Hibs got 4.4 for brown is Gauld not being looked at by top teams like real

6.) 09 Jan 2014
Realistically, these players wouldn't get a chance of playing, so why weaken the premier but buying utd best players

7.) 09 Jan 2014
09 Jan 2014 21:42:57
Simple answer here is NO! can't believe anyone would actually want this move. the club should have the money available to buy these players if that is who we want to sign

i would far far rather keep VVD and not sign any of them than sell him to fund this move. we do not have to sell our best players every year as I am sure he will be vital to us getting cl next season

well done balde and pukki for the goals tonight. missed the match though but by all accounts two good performances and the team from what I hear put in a good display also

8.) 10 Jan 2014
Gauld Armstrong Robertson Mackay Steven Gavin gunning may. If we snap up any of them I'll be happy. Give it another season see if we can prise Russell back to the spfl.

9.) 10 Jan 2014
Just on another note. I want these guys in our team. Young and Scots or Irish for gunning but I always find myself wondering a bout our youth set up. Do our young bhoys, who romp their league, not have the ability required? If our boys were at another club would we want to sign them? If so . Why aren't they getting a shot especially this season? Forgot to sign in. Then typed all this.
ParadiseAndy