15 Aug 2024 11:34:28
Hearing that Mccowan could be very much on and it would be done before end of window he's keen on move as it's to us so I would be well excited also I hear there's a young lad Fran Perez could be on the way talks at a very early stage but again if true these two signings could be wonderful.
Future looks bright future looks green.
15 Aug 2024 12:31:55
McCowan is a massive Celtic fan but I don’t think he would be good enough.
He would be a great signing for Hibs.
He’s a good penalty taker but he can’t take Celtic penalties sitting on the bench.
Ange and our recruitment team should’ve went for Lewis Ferguson when he was at Aberdeen.
15 Aug 2024 13:35:55
The simple question is, is he any better than David Turnbull? If not, why are we even considering him. It’s very easy to stand out at a club like Dundee when there no pressure and no limelight.
15 Aug 2024 14:15:42
I'd say he's probably more dynamic and physical than Turnbull, albeit I've seen him a limited number of times. Either way, we've never replaced the goals Turnbull brought off the bench so if it's not McCowan it needs to be somebody else.
15 Aug 2024 15:06:36
It’s been reported that Hibs have now made a 3rd bid of £750k for McCowan.
15 Aug 2024 15:19:10
David turnbull was shockingly bad and this is now being shown since his move to cardiff. He has been rank since moving there. Same as MJ, he lasted longer than he should at celtic.
Mccowan looks decent and might be a decent squad player but noting more.
Id much rather miller from motherwell.
15 Aug 2024 16:47:20
If its a choice between McGowan and Engels, it's Engels all day for me but the fee may be the issue there. McGowan as someone already said looks good in Dundee team and tbh would hecreally challenge for a first team spot.
Media are trying to say Engels has told friends he wants to come here. Maybe a loan to buy, so that we can all be stressed out at the same time next year ?.
15 Aug 2024 17:15:14
If Celtic are genuinely interested in McCowan they have to beat Hibs to the punch, as it will be much easier to do business with Dundee rather than Hibs, as previous experience shows.
15 Aug 2024 17:31:39
Would love to see the boy Engels signed, however I think this would mean MOR is away. Would prefer MOR to stay for one more year, however Atalanta seem determined to sign him.
15 Aug 2024 19:16:00
No offence to the lad but he’s not needed and nowhere near the required quality for Celtic, the only reason I can think of is being interested is to add more homegrown players when it comes to Europe, that’s it.
He’s a Hibs, hearts or Aberdeen standard at the very best, we should be looking to give younger boys in our academy a chance and better opportunity to the first team instead of going after mediocre players.
15 Aug 2024 22:12:56
He is nowhere near good enough for Europe, I would rather see us spending the money we would use on him to invest in decent contracts for our own youth players if and it's a big if BR thinks there are any youth players that are good enough.