Celtic banter 53085


Use our rumours form to send us celtic transfer rumours.

(single word yields best result)

09 Mar 2021 09:40:30
I've looked at the statistics involving a few goalkeepers due to the speculation that Celtic are looking at Hibs keeper Marciano.
Marciano is no better than Bain.
But I think Dundee Utd Siegrist could be the answer to our problems.
Barkas and Bain have only had 47 saves between them in 27 league games this season.
Compare that to Siegrist who's had 41 saves in his last 6 league games.
Marciano has had 67 league saves this season compared to 120 from Siegrist.
I believe Dundee Utd would be fighting a relegation battle if it wasn't for their keeper.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Mar 2021 09:44:05
As you're Buzz aware I mentioned Siegrist on Sunday.
The way things are going we'll need a new No.1 and back keepers for next season.

09 Mar 2021 10:16:39
I'd be more interested in save percentage. he has made far more save due to the fact he faces far more shots. I'd assume this is the same if you compared man City goalkeeper to Sheffield utd.

09 Mar 2021 10:38:02
The Dundee Utd keeper has a 78% save rate in the league.
Marciano has 73%.
Bain 72%
Barkas has a shocking 62%
Hazard of Celtic actually has a 92% save rate in only 5 league games.
McGregor has an 86% save rate in league games but that drops to 70% when European games are added.

09 Mar 2021 11:08:46
Buzz - I try not to judge SPL keepers against Celtic or Sevco as they always raise their game.

I do look at performances when I can when they play against their own level in terms of opposition. Now recently Dundee Utd lost by 5 or 6 goals against St Mirren who are not remotely prolific - did anyone see how Siegrist performed in that game?

Barkas may well come good if he gets another chance or if he even wants one but I feel that no SPL player at a present is worth considering for Celtic as there is no improvement in what we have at the club.

09 Mar 2021 11:15:52
Buzz utd are mince and constantly under pressure, every save on Sunday he should have made, contrast that with bain he had one save of note and made an arse of it and got lucky. I'd give marshal a 2 year deal he's 35 but imo still very good just look at sevcos keeper. I think we should have signed him last year and saved the 5 mill.

09 Mar 2021 11:52:28
Buzz I would take the two of them👍.

09 Mar 2021 11:55:10
Kev T2
Siegrist only made ONE save against St. Mirren and conceded 5 goals.
Recently against Livingston he made 9 saves.
Against Sevco he made 7 saves and then on Sunday he made 12 saves.

09 Mar 2021 12:18:24
Marshall is a very good shout.

09 Mar 2021 13:47:13
Kev T2
I’ve just noticed that Siegrist never played against St. Mirren when his replacement keeper only made one save.
It’s the only game he’s missed since November.
It probably shows how much Dundee Utd have depended on him this season.

09 Mar 2021 13:54:28
Poor keeper will probably never recover with them stats Buzz 😂😂.

09 Mar 2021 16:27:52
Bring Back Packie Bonner and he'll do a better job than what we have, all we have to do is match his pension.

09 Mar 2021 17:45:06
I know the majority were against it, be we should have signed Joe Hart at the beginning of the season.

09 Mar 2021 21:41:10
RJ Joe Hart would have been a good signing in my opinion.



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass