21 Feb 2021 11:53:39
Who would u rather have holy goalie or the Great Wall?
21 Feb 2021 12:08:18
foster by a long way ability wise for me.
21 Feb 2021 12:32:28
Definitely Forster.
Boruc was a good keeper when focused and in shape.
But he ended up a calamity, when his standards dropped dramatically.
Celtic have always struggled with goalkeepers in my lifetime (1970s) .
I was never a Bonner fan, he was overrated.
Craig Gordon was the best keeper I seen at Celtic until Forster came.
It was a massive mistake letting Craig go this season because Lenny’s teams don’t use the keeper with as many pass backs and Craig having the ball at his feet was his weakness.
21 Feb 2021 12:33:11
Boruc McGrain Elliot VVD Tierney.
21 Feb 2021 12:46:27
JFP, how about Forster and McNeil inplace of Boruc and Elliot?
21 Feb 2021 13:30:54
Ooh Artur Boruc
The Holy Goalie
He blessed himself at Ibrox
and Sevco went off their nut
Case closed 😋😋😋.
21 Feb 2021 13:45:26
Pedro
This will start keyboard warfare but I think ON HIS DAY in my humble opinion Boruc was the best goalkeeper I’ve seen at Celtic Park. Buzz Bomb is correct that's when he was focused and in shape but his standards as Buzz said fell by the wayside. But considering Boruc and Forster at their best I think Boruc was better.
Beyond a shadow of a doubt up until VVD Paul Eliot was the best centre half I’ve seen at the club. Dominant and lost nothing in the air exactly what we’re crying out for at the moment. If we’d had Boruc in goal and Eliot at centre half this season we’d be nearer where we should be despite all our other failings in a season which seems to be one long drawn out monumental act of self harm.
This is the bit I’m expecting a kicking for I think both VVD and Elliot were better than big Billy who I don’t think was in that class although he’d other attributes to compensate none more so than he was a leader. I grudge putting VVD and KT in there because of how short a time they spent at the club. Big Billy is a Celtic legend for me VVD and KT are not. I don’t remember him playing well enough but their are many fans who would have Tommy Gemmell another Celtic legend at full back before Tierney. He was once asked talk us through your goal in the European Cup Final to which he gave the classic response ‘Whit wan son? ’.
21 Feb 2021 13:50:06
He was a mad man tae boot. His John Paul 2 T-shirt was a classic. 😂.
21 Feb 2021 14:07:19
JFP, I always respect your thought's and views on here.
After all, that's what the site is all about.
21 Feb 2021 14:20:40
As pointed out we had never been blessed with good goalies.
Boruc was the first GK we had that turly impressed me (I'm going from 1980 to today) .
However, in answer to your question, I would take Forster over Boruc, just because he was more consistent in his time at Celtic but both are great keepers, so would be happy with any of them.
21 Feb 2021 15:51:05
Agreed LAW, loved big Packie (a Burntonport man) a good keeper but coming out for crosses was never his strength.
21 Feb 2021 16:01:23
Foster great shot stopper boric commanded his area better du? Both great on there day hh.