Celtic banter 43788


Use our rumours form to send us celtic transfer rumours.

(single word yields best result)

23 May 2019 13:33:01
Ed what is the goal scoring stats for all competitions this season?

{Ed007's Note - What do you mean mate?}

Agree0 Disagree3

23 May 2019 14:52:37
How many did each player score this season for us in total of every competitions?
Your always got the Info handy. 😂.

{Ed007's Note - www.skysports.com/celtic-stats

23 May 2019 15:46:28
Cheers ed.

{Ed007's Note - 👍

23 May 2019 16:04:21
I have to say at this point Kev mate, a player we've went toe to toe over -Jamesy Forrest. Second top scorer. I still don't think he's an intelligent player and far from the finished article but I think BR really coached him to channel his runs and it has paid this season. McGregor was our player of the season for me; but I see Forrest has just been named SP player of the year. Well done him. Here's hoping such form continues. I really like the look of Shved mind but looking at him on youtube he can play quite centrally too so we might even see them in the same side.

23 May 2019 16:24:29
Jim I thought it could have went either way with the POTY awards but think Forrest pipped it because on some real important goals.

What I found quite amusing is the 17 is Forrests best return for goals.
Sinclair scored the same in his worse season and people want he drummed out.

23 May 2019 16:42:28
It's undoubtedly Forrest's best season.

I'm not saying I want him drummed out, but sometimes you've got to shift the pack in order to make new signings and I'd probably keep Forrest over Sinclair right now due to a few factors. I only say this because a player I'd like us to go for is Robert Skov. Have a look. Knows his way to goal, pace, scores some crackers and can hit a mean dead ball. He plays in from the right though and shoots with his left which is how I like my wide men.

Could Forrest do even better off our left shooting on his right? Was he getting played on the right because of Sinclair's impact on the left?

And how many pens has Sinclair scored though? I know they need putting away but what if it was Forrest on pens and not Sinclair? Like I say, don't want him pushed out necessarily - he's way down the list. But he has taken a real dip which you've pretty much said.

23 May 2019 16:50:45
JimTim I agree regarding Shved. I would hate to see him stuck behind Forrest waiting on an opportunity. I think he can play the number 10 role. Nobody has that nailed down for me even though I think Christie has had a great season. Rogic far too inconsistent. Shved could very well find himself in that role.

23 May 2019 17:22:01
Jim it's only 4 pens sinky has scored this season but end of the day they have to be scored.

23 May 2019 17:36:23
For me Ice Man Rogic is done. Certainly in the firat XI anyway. Said at the end of last season unless we got a proper season out of him he can go. And we haven't. Granted, I'd need to see more of Shved in the hoops to see if he could play that no10 CAM role. What's his ball playing, intelligence, work-rate like? That sort of thing I haven't seen from youtube. I'd have Christie in that role over Rogic no doubt. I've got my doubts about whether he could be a real top player there though. I rate him as I think he's a good modern CM, and can play CAM when asked to, but one that has probably found his level.

23 May 2019 17:42:30
FOUR? Did the people no get that in one game? They do need scoring but i prefer to judge players returns on open play. Might just be my tapped head but there you go.

23 May 2019 18:10:19
Forrest about 10 or 11 assists as well as his goals though, Sinclair has 2 or 3 assists for me isn't nearly enough for a winger.

23 May 2019 18:35:28
Royjac Sinclair has out assisted every player for 2 of the 3 seasons he's been at the club.

Jim even if you take the 4 pens out the equation he only drops to 3rd place.

23 May 2019 19:41:42
Kev I get that you like Sinky fair enough, for a winger he should be getting more than 2 or 3 assists in a season. It's not enough, he is a one trick pony who has now been found out hence the reason he is not getting the same amount of goals or assists as his first 2 seasons. Is it a confidence thing I don't know, I'm sure he has missed 2 or 3 pens this season also.

23 May 2019 19:56:00
Kev, we might not agree on Lennon but I think we do on Sinclair. I think a lot of people judge him against his first season which was astounding. No one could keep up that level of performance year on year. In my opinion, he’s a top quality winger who we are lucky to have at the club. He takes the pens because he’s good at it. You lose him, you lose that as well.

23 May 2019 21:19:15
Forrest said himself a while back he was trying to mirror what Sinclair does to get amongst the goals more and it's certainly paid off for him this season. Sinky seems to be one of the few that tries to make runs in behind defences maybe Rogic needs to take a page out of his book as he seems to be void of any criticism when he isn't half as productive as Sinclair.

23 May 2019 22:31:45
Royjac if his one trick as you put it is putting the ball in the net regularly that will do me fine.
That guy has 60 goals and around 40 assist in the last 3 seasons.
I would be very very surprised if anyone else's stats come anywhere near that.

23 May 2019 22:37:05
I would sell Rogic personally, yea he is a good player sometimes but is inconsistent lazy and struggles to last a game. Add to that he always injured. Not what we need I'm afraid.

25 May 2019 12:15:00
Sinclair is a higher standard of player. He can play poor and still contribute with key moments. He is playing poor overall but he still has quality.



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass