Celtic Banter Archive March 07 2019

07 Mar 2019 22:53:20
Would anybody fancy Marcus Rose to be our new manager. I would love this. His team has shown us a lesson in Europe a few times. Plus salt burg play good attacking football.

08 Mar 2019 00:03:30
Imagine if his Celtic team got the same result as his Salzburg did tonight at Napoli, he would be getting pelters on here 😉.

08 Mar 2019 07:18:35
Napoli are a Quality side not a surprising result.

08 Mar 2019 11:15:07
I'd take him in a heartbeat but also I'd have no problems with Lennon getting it if he bags the treble. I had my concerns that Lenny would be too volatile and we can't afford to have a gaffer in the stands for weeks at a time when we're so close to the 10, but he seems a bit more calm these days.

08 Mar 2019 12:28:18
Salzburg had 21 shots at goal away to Napoli, so they were unlucky to lose 3-0.
I want Lenny to be our next permanent manager but if we were to appoint a foreign manager I wouldn't have a problem with it being the Salzburg coach because he ticks all the boxes.

08 Mar 2019 13:38:16
NL would be a step backwards and it's as simple as that for me.

08 Mar 2019 13:44:52
I would take him in a heart beat but why would he leave to come to us, when he has just beat us twice in a season? I think this one is a non starter for me. It will be Lennon or clarke (hopefully lennon)

08 Mar 2019 16:20:49
Lennon every day of the week for me. If not Lenny the Marco Rose would be my number 1 choice.

This is just my opinion but if you look beyond the fact that Lennon is a Celtic man who has played, captained and Manged the club before as well as working with Lawwell and the board in my opinion Lennon is a very talented and knowledgeable manager who has fantastic qualities. His teams play an attacking and attractive brand of football and he demands the best out of his players both individually and as a team.

08 Mar 2019 17:12:37
As long as there are a decent amount put into the transfer kitty then onwards we go for 9 in a row.

07 Mar 2019 13:14:20
It's been a while so plenty to discuss. Just my take on what's happened on and off the park since the summer so any feedback welcome.

I'll start with the main issue, Brendan Rodgers. From the outside looking in it looks like the McGinn saga was what started a very strained relationship between Rodgers and the Board. From that moment onwards i think he made up his mind to leave and the Board were aware of it. We then have a situation where another transfer window comes around and we are expected to get things right. On paper it didn't look too impressive, loan signings and projects like Bayo and Shved who will have no impact this season. Have to say results since have shown the Board got it spot on, why would they give Rodgers x amount of cash if he had made up his mind his future was elsewhere. Guys like Burke and Weah 'get it' and Burkes comment that he is here to play for Celtic and it doesn't matter who the manager is was class, would love both these deals to be extended.

This brings me to players positions, Rodgers had his flaws and this was one of them. How many times have we seen players out of position. McGregor at Left back at Ibrox, id have rather seen a youth player there so that we had McGregor 'our player of the moment' doing what he does best. We also have Calvin Miller, a player who was voted best youngster on the planet (Left Midfield) . Rodgers could have ruined this lads career before it has even started, yes great that he learns how to defend but as i said previously on here let him go express himself with the ball, long term we can have himself Johnston and Oxo-Flex all fighting for that position, his natural position. Hopefully the new Manager ends this failed attempt to make him a left back. There's countless others. Add to this not dropping favourites who were playing badly, or being unable to change tactics against teams that were quite simply better than us proves he had plenty flaws. In my opinion he also handled the Boyata situation badly.

Moving forward we currently have a nucleus of great young talent, Ajer, Henderson, Tierney, Johnston, Ralston, Miller, Forrest, Christie, Oxo-Flex, Dembele, Church, McInroy, Aitchison etc so the future is bright. If we can continue to add to this group with one or 2 quality additions each window i will be happy. We also have Griffiths return to look forward to, i have missed seeing him play. People can point fingers all they like about who's right and who's wrong but when you look at the facts, on and off the pitch we are in a very good position. Yes, plenty work to do in the summer but we have a good base to start from. I really have no idea on who the new Manager should be, I think if Lenny gets the League and Cup in the bag he will be given the chance to go for 9, i have no issues with that although i would also have no issues with the club looking elsewhere if the right candidate was available, to take the club forward on and off the pitch, like Rodgers did in many ways.

Sorry for the 'story like' post but it's been a long time since posting and i've not had the chance to read the site for months so again sorry if you have had to read or reply to similar posts constantly. To cut a very long story short there is life after Brendan Rodgers, I thank him for his success but he has been wiped from our history books as far as i am concerned and i hope he never returns. The building blocks are in place for a bright future at CFC, as long as we do not get complacent and continue to grow we will be ok. Looking forward to the Treble Treble and the rebuilding this summer. We will become stronger without people who do not wish to be at our club.

Let's all get behind the club, Lenny and the players and see where we are in May.

Stan.

07 Mar 2019 13:22:11
Well summed up Stan the future looks bright jyst need a couple of cbs and we'll be fine.

07 Mar 2019 13:33:33
Great post Stan totally agree.

Griffiths is a major concern for me though, I would be surprised if he played for us again. Hope he is on the mend but concerned at some point he may decide not to play again. Would be a shame if he did, but end of the day health should always come first.

07 Mar 2019 14:15:21
Excellent post Stan and I hope we see Griffiths againin the green and white because in my opinion we would never be able to sell him. I say this because as some of those in lala land think Morelos is worth 30m then Griffiths is PRICELESS.

07 Mar 2019 14:44:40
Very good summary Stan - and I only want to add my appreciation and support for NL and the players during this turbulent time; producing two great wins in Edinburgh inside a week (despite Collum lol) and if they carry on this winning run against Aberdeen on Saturday, it will be a magnificent reflection of the players focus, ability and appetite despite massive disruption and distraction.
Well done Celtic.

07 Mar 2019 15:08:18
Good post Stan, good to see u back! Only thing I disagree on is I wouldn't thank Rodgers he should be thanking us. He used us to his advantage and left when we were no longer needed, he's shown us the true man he is, not a celtic man and never was.

07 Mar 2019 15:25:53
As everyone has said great post Stan.
There's no point in looking back we all have to move forward and support the Bhoys to the Treble Treble.
On a plus note, as your post was so sensible. Any ideas on how to sort out this Brexit nonsense! 😂😂.

07 Mar 2019 15:55:58
Sorry GT10 I only write 1 sensible post per season so that's me all out already 😂.

07 Mar 2019 18:07:08
By the way, just realised something. Griffiths has a far better goals per game ratio and scored against better teams than rapid Vienna in Europe compared to Morelos. How much is Griffiths worth if Morelos is allegedly 20m.

07 Mar 2019 19:54:59
What about his goals for Scotland against In-Ger-Lund.
Priceless.

07 Mar 2019 09:31:52
Caught the end of the man utd - psg match last night. IMO never a penalty but got me thinking that if it was Celtic in that position instead of Man Utd, would we have got a penalty? No chance.

07 Mar 2019 09:40:18
If your arm is up you are always in danger of giving a pen away.

07 Mar 2019 10:11:01
Never a pen Henrik and that's with var but was surprised ajax being the smaller club got the decision against real.

07 Mar 2019 11:09:14
Further proof that VAR will cause just as many problems and mistakes as it solves. I always believed that it was ball-to-hand - thus 'Hand-Ball' and this unnatural position nonsense will always be a matter of opinion, varying from ref to ref and a penalty awarded when a player has his back to play and doesn't even know where the ball is heading can never be intentional.
As for the Real Madrid game, one camera angle showed the ball clearly out of play, but for some reason it was over-ruled?
VAR will cause a riot up here - trust me.

07 Mar 2019 11:46:57
When refs get trained they are told to watch position of arm when its a handball. If the arm is in an unatural position then most refs will give a penalty.

{Ed007's Note - This is what UEFA told refs this summer regarding their competitions:

07 Mar 2019 13:17:29
Under that explaintion it's a penalty then ed.

{Ed007's Note - I read somewhere last night though that it's different rules in the EPL.}

08 Mar 2019 18:47:30
I just think Celtic wouldn't get a penalty in domestic football in that instance .
On the other hand, if this example happened in Celtic's defensive area a penalty would be awarded.