18 Mar 2017 16:33:39
It may not be popular but I can't help but be impressed with Shay Logan, always consistent and never seems to have a bad game.


1.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 17:12:41
No for me ray got to look higher than him plus he's a nob.


2.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 16:59:24
Nope not for me, don't rate him and he looks a rite f@nny!


3.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 19:39:20
He's consistently good for Aberdeen but he's not the type of player we need to take us up a level. Plus a lot of our fans seem to dislike him after the Tonev incident.


4.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 21:01:43
Is shay Logan only a knob because he supposedly got racially abused, or is there another reason?


5.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 21:47:33
id taks him aswell rayman boys no a bad player at all.

{Ed007's Note - So sign a 29 year old mediocre RB and then what? Sell Lustig who has just signed a new 2 year deal or sell Gamboa who is 2 years younger than - and a far better player than - Logan who's not even been here a year?
Tony Ralston in the Development squad is pushing for a first team chance and there's also Sam Wardrop and Josh Kerr who I'd rather give a chance than sign Logan.
The only player in Scottish football we should be thinking of signing is John McGinn from Hibs.}


6.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 23:06:13
Agree with the McGinn comment from 007 thought we should have taken him when he left st Mirren remember him being a standout player for them and gave Scot Brown a torrid time have not seen him play for Hibs though.

{Ed007's Note - My mate that scouts for Accies has watched him a lot more than me over the years and said the same as you, D, we should have signed him from St Mirren. I've only watched a few Hibs games this season but he always looks the part and works his socks off.
I know that's still Championship level but we would - and have - happily send our youngsters to Hibs on loan so why not take a punt on him? He'd fit into that wee 'clique' of young Scots besides the likes of Tierney, Armstrong, Henderson, McGregor even Forrest and he would be more than capable of playing in any domestic games for us.}


7.) 18 Mar 2017
18 Mar 2017 23:11:28
We still have Janko on the books as well, but doesn't seem to be featuring much for Barnsley.

{Ed007's Note - I forgot about him! I can't seeing him having any future with us but he's still only 21 and got a couple of years on his contract. Maybe a move to Nottingham Forest for a couple of million? ;)


8.) 19 Mar 2017
19 Mar 2017 08:51:02
Only player I would have from Scotland is patterson from hearts.
I rate him.
Good defender and is dangerous going forward. Reminds me of Lustig and I think he will develop into a right good player if his next move is the right one.


9.) 19 Mar 2017
19 Mar 2017 10:20:23
Agree witb ed the bhoy ralston could turn out a player for us if he's given a chance and my opinion of logan is purely based on ability and character nothing to do with the racist comments but again he's a knob.


10.) 19 Mar 2017
19 Mar 2017 17:10:43
Don't think I would sign Logan just like the look of him didn't realise he's 29.
Just think we need an improvement on Lustig.
If u look at the left hand side KT is always backing Sinky up ad overlapping and are a good partnership and this is our best attacking option.

Right hand side while Lustig is a good defender he seems to let Forrest go and not back him up, there is very little interplay between them.
Just think a more athletic younger right back might be needed.