06 Apr 2018 19:18:31
Im hoping that there is little interest in Armstrong come the summer transfer window.
That combined with Celtic putting a very competitive offer to him. I think SA wants to try his luck elsewhere, however we must try and offer him a good deal to stay.
So here`s a question
out of these 2 players if you could only choose 1 to stay, who would you choose
Rogic or Armstrong.?
My choice: Armstrong.
whats your thoughts folks?
06 Apr 2018 19:38:50
Rogic - has moments of world class, however they are moments and is missing quite a lot in games
Armstrong - More all round ability and can drop deeper than Rogic to help midfield. However no single ability that stands out.
Tbh I think with these tactics we need a CAM who can do both. Musonda was suppose to be the quick and fitter option for that position along with the skill. So we will see if he is up to it next season.
06 Apr 2018 19:53:52
I'd have to toss a coin.
06 Apr 2018 20:35:59
Both offer a lot of different strengths and positives and both can score goals - although I think Rogic has a gifted natural ability on the ball that is a joy to watch, whereas Armstrong has more energy.
However, there have always been stamina and fitness/ injury problems with Rogic and he tends to miss parts of a season, but I think Armstrong is less committed to Celtic long term and if Rogic was offered a more acceptable contract he would be easier to keep.
07 Apr 2018 00:45:46
I would have to say that I would rather have a fully fit Armstrong in my team than a Rogic, if it was a choice between the two, but I would rather play both.
07 Apr 2018 11:13:23
Rogic in my opinion, when fully fit has the potential to be an extraordinary player, close control, first touch, ball retention, passing, decent tackling. Love watching him play and usually gets involved in the big games with the goals needed.
Armstrong great two feet but can't ever see him more than a Steven Davis, good work rate but not built to be a box to box and at times lacks the heart to put himself about - get involved in a war line Broony.
Rogic is my pick. Could buy another Armstrong but find replacing Rogic difficult.
07 Apr 2018 22:07:30
Rogic is the most skilful attacking player we have . However he never gives us 45 mins of football. I think he is old now to have his full speed and stamina . To me good and all that he is, he doesn't give us enough to be a consistent starter .
Armstrong reminds me a bit of what I think is an old fashioned inside left, he can defend a bit, link up play but is excellent at breaking into the box and provides a good goal threat . His break recovering from hernia, seems to have brought him back to his very best form of last season .
I don't want a whole pile of speculation will he won't he, I just want a yes or a no in the summer.
07 Apr 2018 22:07:30
Rogue is the most skilful attacking player we have . However he never gives us 45 mins of football. I think he is too old now to have his full speed and stamina . To me good and all that he is, he doesn't give us enough to be a consistent starter .
Armstrong reminds me a bit of what I think is an old fashioned inside left, he can defend a bit, link up play but is excellent at breaking into the box and provides a good goal threat . His break recovering from hernia, seems to have brought him back to his very best form of last season .
I don't want a whole pile of speculation will he won't he, I just want a yes or a no in the summer.
{Ed033's Note - Rogue is a superhuman mutant