Celtic banter 38318


Use our rumours form to send us celtic transfer rumours.

(single word yields best result)

09 Mar 2018 21:36:01
John McGinn having a stormer tonight. He seems to be one of those players who either does nothing all game or looks a world beater.

Agree8 Disagree0

09 Mar 2018 22:41:35
Agree Kevbhoy, he was excellent and his value increases week on week. Would take him and sell SA in a heartbeat.

10 Mar 2018 06:18:33
Maybe that's the Celtic midfield of the near future, John McGinn and Scott Alan.

10 Mar 2018 09:09:58
All 3 were outstanding last night. McGinn Will go to England and be a star. Only chance we have of getting him is by offering 2 or 3 fringe players plus cash because we have missed out our chance to buy him for anything less than £3.5m.

10 Mar 2018 09:23:38
Maybe Rodgers giving Hibs the green light to sign Allan could be our chance for us to offer him plus cash for McGinn. Good day that he's playing well there as it is boosting Allan's valuation too. Still could get McGinn for £3.5m plus Allan and a 10% sell on. Especially if Armstrong is likely to be off in the summer.

10 Mar 2018 10:09:00
A stormer? I honestly think he was nothing better than average last night, and for me Mcgeough was by far their best player. don't get me wrong i think the boys a good player but over 3m?

10 Mar 2018 10:18:55
He is out of contract next summer so I can't see him going for as much as 3.5M.

If Celtic are interested in him, both him and his agent will know about it.

If Rodgers does want him, I can see us bidding in the summer, if they are asking ridiculous money, we will wait until January and go back with a smaller offer. If they don't play ball we will get him for free next summer.

10 Mar 2018 11:00:11
Mcginns long range passing was class last night, also his drive and close control. Amongst BR and the players at Celtic he would be even better. Celtic can't allow him to go to England. Whether we can get him timr will tell.

10 Mar 2018 11:56:14
McGinn was just as good as any Hibs player last night, he was ok at best

He’s not good enough for Celtic and will be a Barnsley player at best when he goes to England.

10 Mar 2018 12:08:36
Sometimes we forget what we have; and at present we have Brown, Eboue, Ntcham, McGregor, Biton, Armstrong and Rogic all with European, or International experience - and better than McGinn.
That doesn't include Benyu and other attacking midfield players like Forrest, Roberts, Musonda and Hayes when he returns.
So unless we are having a clear-out in the summer, he would struggle to get into the team IMO.

10 Mar 2018 12:15:13
Thought mcgeoch was best player on park and alans goal had been scored by Messi or Ronaldo it would have been raved about.

10 Mar 2018 12:26:24
Once a bhoy, this is only an opinion but, ebuoe doesn't look up to to it . Biton is back up defender at most. Armstrong and rogic will both be away in the summer . Roberts will go back to man city unless they sell for under 5 million ( will probably go to a stoke or Sunderland) . I've seen nothing from benyu to suggest he can make the first team regularly and hayes is just a baffling buy altogether . Will end out on loan to Aberdeen or hibs next season . Remember how long it took broony to get to where he is now . Mcginn maybe worth a punt as he holds his own in this league already .

{Ed007's Note - Sunderland are rooted to the bottom of the English Championship and will likely get relegated so they won't be buying Roberts to play in League One.}

10 Mar 2018 13:07:18
Time will tell if McGinn is good enough at Celtic or a higher level but to suggest now he is not is just ridiculous. No wonder Scotland is doom and gloom people constantly being negative towards our better youngsters. God help him if he does come to Celtic the knives will be out the minute he kicks a ball from the i told you so brigade. Have a bit of faith for the love of god.

10 Mar 2018 13:10:26
Am with u Stan av always liked mcginn and would take a punt.

10 Mar 2018 13:48:47
I haven't seen anything from Mcginn that suggests he will ever be good enough for Celtic.
Callum McGregor is the same age, is a far better player and loads of Celtic fans wanted him bomd out of parkhead till recently.

10 Mar 2018 14:05:23
McGinn was the best player on the park for Scotland against Holland at Pittodrie. Yes he may have had some poor games (like all players) but i will judge him on the games where he looked the part, ie at Parkhead in September etc.

10 Mar 2018 14:05:51
U know what a meant ed 🤣🤣 bottom epl team possible who ever gets promotion from the championship . I would love it if he signed permanent but surely man city would have to lower their price ed? But my original point is, mcginn would be worth the risk .

10 Mar 2018 15:12:17
What's wrong with mcginn and Callum in same team get got more aggression than Callum they're different types.



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass